Grant Vs Forgivable Vs Repayable Down Payment Assistance — The Quick Read: A grant is money released at closing that a buyer never repays, but it comes with an income test and a homebuyer education class. A forgivable second is a real loan that disappears if the buyer keeps making on-time payments on the first mortgage long enough. A repayable second is a real loan with its own monthly payment and a balloon due down the road. The right one depends on how long the buyer plans to stay put, how tight the monthly budget is, and whether they fit a qualifying category for the grant.
Buyers hear “down payment assistance” and picture one thing: free cash. That’s true for exactly one of the three shapes covered here. The other two are loans, just structured very differently from a typical mortgage, and the differences matter more than most buyers realize until they try to sell or refinance a few years in.
None of these options require a first-time buyer. A repeat buyer moving up, a public-service worker upgrading from a rental, or someone who owned a home years ago but sold it can all potentially qualify, depending on which shape fits their file. Buyers exploring down payment assistance programs often start by figuring out which of the three structures below matches their timeline and their monthly budget — that’s the real decision, not the dollar amount.
Key Terms Defined
Minimum required investment (MRI): the smallest share of the purchase price or appraised value an FHA borrower must contribute, set at 3.5% for most credit profiles.
Forgivable second lien: a second loan behind the first mortgage that gets wiped out entirely after the borrower makes a set number of on-time payments on the first lien.
Repayable second lien: a second loan that carries its own monthly payment and comes due in a lump sum (a balloon) after a set number of years.
Combined loan-to-value (CLTV): the first mortgage plus any second lien, measured against the home’s value — lenders cap this to control total debt against the property.
Homebuyer education: a HUD-approved course required for certain assistance options, confirming the buyer understands the obligations tied to the mortgage and any assistance layered on it.
Side-by-Side
| Factor | Grant | Forgivable Second | Repayable Second |
|---|---|---|---|
| Repayment | None — nothing owed | Forgiven after 36 or 60 on-time payments | Amortizing, balloon due year 10 |
| Credit floor | 620 | 640 (660 blended) | 660 (670 blended) |
| Income test | 140% AMI or qualifying category | None beyond USDA’s own limit on a USDA first lien | None beyond USDA’s own limit on a USDA first lien |
| First-lien pairing | FHA only | FHA, HUD-184, USDA | FHA, HUD-184, USDA |
| Counseling required | Yes, HUD-approved course | No | No |
| Manual underwriting | Allowed | Allowed | Not allowed |
When a Grant Is the Better Fit
A grant fits the buyer who qualifies for a specific category and doesn’t want any lien attached to the home. Because the grant is released at closing with nothing to repay, it’s the cleanest option on paper — no monthly payment, no lien to track, no repayment trigger to worry about years later.
The catch is eligibility. The grant option pairs only with an FHA first lien (203(b), FHA repair escrow, Limited 203(k), or Standard 203(k) at 96.5% loan-to-value) and asks the buyer to either fall at or below 140% of area median income or fit a qualifying category — a first responder, an educator, medical personnel, a civil servant, military personnel, a first-time buyer under the three-year ownership rule, or a purchase in an underserved census tract. It covers 2% or 3.5% of the purchase price toward the FHA minimum required investment.
It also asks something of the buyer’s time: a HUD-approved homebuyer education course is required before closing, though the cost gets credited back at closing. And it isn’t available everywhere — the grant option isn’t offered in Washington, and it can’t be stacked with FHA High Balance, FHA $100 Down, FHA 203(h), FHA Good Neighbor Next Door, FHA One-Time Close, or any other assistance program.
Buyers who fit a category and plan to stay in the home for a while tend to like this shape best, since there’s no forgiveness clock running and no balloon payment waiting. A buyer who doesn’t fit any qualifying category and sits above 140% of area median income simply doesn’t have this door open — that’s when the forgivable or repayable second becomes the practical path instead.
When a Forgivable Second Is the Better Fit
A forgivable second works well for a buyer who’s confident they’ll stay in the home long enough to ride out the forgiveness period and who doesn’t fit the grant’s income or category test. It carries no interest and no monthly payment, and it’s wiped out entirely once the borrower completes the first 36 or 60 on-time payments on the first mortgage — no missed payment 90 days or more along the way.
This structure covers 3.5% of the lesser of purchase price or appraised value, and it pairs with a wider set of first liens than the grant: FHA 203(b), FHA Limited 203(k), HUD-184, and USDA, on one- to two-unit properties. Credit floor sits at 640 for a single borrower, 660 when a co-borrower’s lower score gets blended in. There’s no income limit tacked on beyond whatever the USDA first lien itself requires, and no homebuyer education course to sit through.
The tradeoff is real, even though it feels invisible at closing: this is a loan. If the home gets sold, refinanced, or the buyer moves out before the forgiveness period runs its course, part or all of the balance can come due. A buyer who’s job-uncertain, expecting a move, or just not sure how long they’ll stay should weigh that risk carefully — the forgivable second rewards staying put and can penalize an early exit. Someone who thinks they’ll sell in three years probably shouldn’t lean on a five-year forgiveness schedule.
Practicing brokers who place these files regularly notice a pattern: buyers gravitate toward the forgivable second when they’re using a USDA or HUD-184 first lien, since the grant doesn’t pair with either of those loan types. It ends up being less a matter of preference and more a matter of which first mortgage the buyer already qualifies for.
When a Repayable Second Is the Better Fit
A repayable second fits the buyer who needs closing-cost help on top of the down payment and can comfortably carry an extra monthly payment. Unlike the grant or the forgivable second, this is a real interest-bearing loan with its own monthly obligation, amortized over 30 years with a balloon due in year 10. It covers 3.5% of the lesser of purchase price or appraised value for the down payment alone, or 5% when the buyer also needs help with closing costs and prepaid items — in that case 3.5% goes toward the minimum investment and 1.5% goes toward closing costs.
This option pairs with FHA 203(b), FHA Limited 203(k), HUD-184, or USDA first liens on one- to two-unit properties, and unlike the forgivable second, it allows high-balance first liens. Credit floor runs a notch higher at 660 for a single borrower, 670 blended. One meaningful restriction: manual underwriting isn’t permitted here, so the file needs an automated underwriting system approval to move forward. There’s also a closing-cost-only variant that pairs with an FHA 203(b) first lien and covers just closing costs, prepaids, and costs paid outside of closing.
Because this second carries a real monthly payment, it gets counted in the buyer’s debt-to-income ratio during underwriting — a buyer already stretched thin on monthly obligations may find that payment tips their file the wrong way. That’s the honest tradeoff: more flexibility on which first lien it pairs with and higher assistance ceilings, against a real payment every month and a balloon that eventually comes due. Buyers planning to refinance or sell before year 10 need to think through how that balloon gets settled — usually through sale proceeds or a refinance of the whole package.
There’s a fourth variant worth a quick mention: a refinance-cost second, which covers 1% to 3.5% of the lesser of the current first-lien balance or appraised value toward closing costs on an FHA 203(b) refinance, with combined leverage up to 104%. It follows the same repayment terms as the purchase-money repayable second, but it’s built for an existing homeowner refinancing an FHA loan — not a purchase — and it can’t be used to refinance an existing assistance loan or paired with a streamline refinance. Terms vary by lender guidelines, property type, leverage, credit profile, and full file review.
What the File Actually Needs
Every option here sits underneath a real FHA, USDA, or HUD-184 first mortgage, and the first lien has its own rules regardless of which assistance shape a buyer uses. FHA’s Single Family Housing Policy Handbook 4000.1 sets the baseline minimum required investment at 3.5% of the lesser of purchase price or appraised value for most credit profiles, and that handbook governs how FHA lenders originate and document every loan in the program, assistance or not.
USDA’s guaranteed loan program runs under its own regulation, 7 CFR Part 3555, which sets out the purpose of the Single Family Housing Guaranteed Loan Program for low- and moderate-income buyers purchasing in eligible rural areas. Because USDA guaranteed loans are already built around no down payment for eligible borrowers, the forgivable or repayable second tends to show up there covering closing costs rather than the down payment itself.
HUD-184 is a little different again — it carries no income restriction of its own, a fact confirmed in HUD’s own budget documentation on the Indian Housing Loan Guarantee Fund, which means a buyer using an HUD-184 first lien with a forgivable or repayable second isn’t running into an income cap on either layer.
Whichever shape a buyer lands on, every option here is for an owner-occupied primary residence only — never a second home, never a rental, never an investment property. None of the four shapes stack with another down payment assistance program, and a mortgage credit certificate can’t be layered onto either second-lien option.
For the end-to-end picture of how these loans work — qualification, structures, and the full process — see Lendmire’s complete DSCR loans guide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a repeat buyer use any of these options?
Yes. None of the three structures require a first-time buyer. The grant provides 2% or 3.5% of the purchase price with nothing to repay, and it requires a credit score of 620, an FHA first lien, an income at or below 140% of the area median unless a qualifying category applies, and completion of homebuyer education — first-time buyer status is not one of the requirements. A repeat buyer who meets the credit, income, and education criteria can still use the grant, and the forgivable second — 3.5% of the purchase price, forgiven after 36 or 60 on-time first-lien payments — along with the repayable second, carry no first-time-buyer requirement at all.
Does the forgivable second show up on my credit or affect my monthly payment while I’m waiting for forgiveness? It carries no monthly payment and no interest during the forgiveness period. It is recorded as a lien against the property, though, so it does factor into the combined loan-to-value calculation used during underwriting — it just doesn’t add a payment to the household budget.
What happens if I need to sell before the forgivable second is fully forgiven?
Part or all of the remaining balance can become due at that point, since forgiveness depends on completing the required number of on-time payments on the first mortgage. A buyer who expects to move within a few years should weigh that risk against the grant, which has no such trigger, if they happen to qualify for the grant’s income test or a qualifying category.
Can I combine the grant with a USDA or HUD-184 loan?
No. The grant pairs only with an FHA first lien — specifically 203(b), FHA repair escrow, Limited 203(k), or Standard 203(k). Buyers using a USDA or HUD-184 first mortgage would look instead at the forgivable or repayable second, both of which pair with those loan types.
Does the repayable second’s monthly payment affect my ability to qualify for the first mortgage? Yes. Because the repayable second carries a real monthly payment, it’s counted in the debt-to-income ratio during underwriting, alongside the first mortgage payment. A buyer already near their qualifying limit on the first lien should factor that added payment in before assuming the repayable second is the right fit.
Tax treatment can depend on your situation; buyers should speak with a qualified tax professional before relying on any deduction or credit.
If you’re buying a primary home and want to see whether a down payment assistance option fits your file, Lendmire can help you compare the grant, forgivable, and repayable structures alongside an FHA, USDA, or HUD-184 first mortgage, subject to lender guidelines and full underwriting.
Investors who want the broader program framework can review how DSCR loans work.
About Lendmire
Lendmire — NMLS# 2371349 — is a mortgage broker that arranges FHA, USDA and HUD-184 home purchase financing with grant-style, forgivable and repayable down payment assistance options in 16 states through wholesale lenders. Every option is subject to the lender’s guidelines and full underwriting. Scotsman Guide named Lendmire a Top Mortgage Workplace in both 2025 and 2026.
Get Started
Ready to find the right loan for you?
In about 30 seconds you can review financing options available for your home or investment property. No commitment required.
Informational only. Not a Loan Estimate, approval, or commitment to lend. Program availability and eligibility are subject to lender guidelines, credit approval, property review, and underwriting.
References
1. HUD Handbook 4000.1 (SFH Handbook landing page)
This article is part of Lendmire’s down payment assistance program — full qualification details, guidelines, and scenarios live on the program page.
Related reading: How A Repayable Down Payment Assistance Second Affects Your DTI? · Open Vs First-time-only Down Payment Assistance For A Move-up Buyer · Does A Grant Or Repayable Second Skip The Occupancy Requirement?
Brandon Miller
Founder & CEO, Mortgage Loan Originator, Lendmire LLC
- Mortgage Loan Originator · NMLS# 1129696 · Verify on NMLS Consumer Access
- North Carolina Real Estate Broker · License# 343312 · Verify on NCREC
- North Carolina Insurance Producer · License# 19053198 · Property, Casualty, Life, Health · Verify on NAIC SBS
- Lendmire LLC · Firm NMLS# 2371349 · Verify firm licensure
Compliance and disclosures. Lendmire (NMLS# 2371349) is a licensed mortgage broker and is not a direct lender, depository institution, financial advisor, or tax professional. Content in this article is general market analysis and educational information — not financial, legal, or tax advice for any specific situation. Lendmire does not guarantee loan approval; every transaction is subject to underwriting by the funding lender. Mortgage pricing and loan program guidelines are subject to change at any time without notice and vary by borrower characteristics, property type, and state regulations. Lendmire complies with Equal Housing Opportunity. Licensure verification: NMLS Consumer Access.